Showing posts with label feedback.. Show all posts
Showing posts with label feedback.. Show all posts

Sunday, October 9, 2016

The Editor's Review



So as I expected, the editor's review of my manuscript is a mixed bag.  I haven't had the chance to go over more than just the overview.  Much of it is very, very positive.  But there's still a long list of stuff I need to work on.  She didn't immediately discount my characters as unlikeable as at least one of my readers did, but she did give me pointers about how to make them more likeable, which is helpful.  I will have to go through the line by line suggestions.  I'm sure there is much from which I can learn.  And much work to do.

Sigh.  There is no such thing as a manuscript that is perfect.  I just have to achieve publishability.  That's still going to be a long haul.  But at least I know how I can do it.

Tuesday, August 23, 2016

Feedback



It's good to get feedback from other writers.  That's why I rejoined League of Utah Writers after some hiatus.  I went to a different branch of the group before, one, that met in person.  It was really good to get personal feedback, especially from such excellent writers and critiquers.  Several of them are published and really know what they're doing.

However, I found myself going less and less often because life gets hectic.  The way they run it, you bring your text in one time, people take it home and read and critique it thoroughly, and then you get it back with verbal explanations the next time.  It's a good system, but it didn't work for me.  I would have to have driven 20 minutes to get back into town after going home, or I would have had to stick around in town long after it was necessary...two weeks in a row.  It's hard to make a commitment like that.  If I lived in town, it would have been no big deal.  But especially in winter when even the highway can get slick, and fog makes visibility at night impossible, I just rarely went.

Then I discovered a group that met ONLINE.  Some of them aren't even in the same STATE.  I get the sense that most of them are a little more new to the experience of writing, but the group works for me because I can do it on my own time, without the drive.  It does require that I drop everything to critique others' writing once a month, but it's working fairly well for me since I get their critiques in return.  As I said in a different blog last time, I highly recommend a group like this for anyone.